How To Hire a social Media Manager

How do you hire a social media manger? Are they worth it? Should You Go With an Agency?

March 08, 2024

Hiring a social media manager involves defining goals, creating a job description, sourcing and screening candidates, conducting interviews, and onboarding the chosen individual. The ROI of hiring a social media manager can vary, but studies show potential for increased brand awareness, engagement, website traffic, and sales. Hiring a social media manager is worth it if you prioritize social media marketing and want to free up internal resources. To maximize ROI, set clear expectations, provide feedback, encourage creativity, invest in professional development, and track results regularly. Remember, social media is constantly changing, and a dedicated manager can help your brand thrive in this dynamic environment.

Hiring a Social Media Manager

A Comprehensive Guide with Tips and ROI Insights

In today's digital age, social media has become an indispensable tool for businesses to connect with their audience, build brand awareness, and drive sales. However, effectively managing social media presence requires expertise, time, and resources. For many businesses, hiring a social media manager is a strategic investment to ensure their online presence thrives. This comprehensive guide will walk you through the process of hiring a social media manager, delve into the potential ROI, and provide valuable tips for a successful partnership.

Hiring a Social Media Manager: Step-by-Step

  1. Define Your Goals and Expectations:

    • Clearly outline what you want to achieve with social media. Are you aiming to increase brand awareness, drive website traffic, generate leads, or boost sales?

    • Specify the platforms you want to focus on (Facebook, Instagram, Twitter, LinkedIn, etc.) and the type of content you want to create (posts, videos, stories, live sessions).

    • Set measurable key performance indicators (KPIs) to track your social media manager's performance, such as engagement rate, reach, website traffic, and lead generation.

  2. Create a Job Description:

    • Clearly define the role and responsibilities of the social media manager.

    • Outline the required skills and experience, such as content creation, community management, social media advertising, and analytics.

    • Specify the desired personality traits, such as creativity, communication skills, and a passion for social media.

  3. Source and Screen Candidates:

    • Post the job description on relevant job boards, social media platforms, and industry-specific websites.

    • Review resumes and cover letters, looking for candidates who match your requirements and demonstrate a strong understanding of your brand and industry.

    • Conduct initial phone or video interviews to assess candidates' communication skills, experience, and cultural fit.

  4. Conduct In-Depth Interviews:

    • Invite shortlisted candidates for in-depth interviews.

    • Ask scenario-based questions to gauge their problem-solving skills and creativity.

    • Request a portfolio of their previous social media work to assess their style and capabilities.

    • Consider giving them a small paid assignment to evaluate their skills in real-world scenarios.

  5. Check References and Background:

    • Contact the candidates' references to verify their experience and work ethic.

    • Conduct a background check if necessary, especially if the social media manager will have access to sensitive information.

  6. Onboard and Train:

    • Once you've made a decision, formally offer the position to the chosen candidate.

    • Develop a comprehensive onboarding and training plan to familiarize them with your brand, company culture, and social media goals.

    • Provide access to necessary tools and resources, such as social media management software and analytics platforms.

Average ROI of Hiring a Social Media Manager

Determining the average ROI of hiring a social media manager can be challenging, as it depends on various factors, including the manager's experience, the industry, the size of the business, and the effectiveness of the social media strategy. However, several studies have indicated positive returns on investment for businesses that hire social media professionals.

A study by the CMO Survey found that companies that invested in social media marketing saw an average return of 243% on their investment. Another study by Nielsen revealed that brands that actively engage with their audience on social media experience a 20% increase in customer loyalty.

The ROI of hiring a social media manager can be measured through various metrics, such as:

  • Increased website traffic

  • Higher engagement rates (likes, comments, shares)

  • Increased brand awareness and reach

  • Improved lead generation and sales

  • Enhanced customer service and satisfaction

  • Positive brand sentiment and reputation

Is Hiring a Social Media Manager Worth It?

The decision to hire a social media manager depends on your business's specific needs and resources. However, if you're serious about leveraging social media to achieve your marketing goals, having a dedicated professional can be a valuable investment.

A social media manager can bring a wealth of knowledge and experience to your organization, including:

  • Expertise in social media platforms and trends

  • Content creation and curation skills

  • Community management and engagement strategies

  • Social media advertising and analytics expertise

  • Time and resource management

By freeing up your time and resources, a social media manager allows you to focus on your core business activities while ensuring your social media presence is handled effectively.

Tips for Maximizing the ROI of Your Social Media Manager

  • Set clear goals and expectations.

  • Provide regular feedback and communication.

  • Encourage creativity and experimentation.

  • Invest in professional development opportunities.

  • Empower your social media manager to make decisions.

  • Foster a collaborative and supportive environment.

  • Track and measure results regularly.

By following these tips and investing in a skilled social media manager, you can unlock the full potential of social media marketing and achieve significant returns on investment. Remember, social media is an ever-evolving landscape, and having a dedicated expert on your team can help you stay ahead of the curve and build a thriving online community around your brand.

The decision to hire an agency or an individual social media manager depends on your company's specific needs, budget, and goals.

Hiring an Agency (like Buter Up social media):

  • Pros: Access to a team of specialists with diverse skills (content creation, strategy, advertising, analytics), scalability to handle larger campaigns, established processes and resources, potential for fresh perspectives and innovative ideas.

  • Cons: Higher cost compared to an individual manager, less direct control over day-to-day activities, potential communication challenges with multiple team members.

Hiring an Individual Social Media Manager:

  • Pros: More affordable option, direct communication and collaboration, personalized attention to your brand, potential for a deeper understanding of your company culture and values.

  • Cons: Limited expertise in all areas of social media, potential for burnout or limited bandwidth for larger campaigns, less access to specialized resources and tools.

Choosing Buter Up social media (or another agency):

Buter Up social media might be a good fit if you:

  • Have a larger budget and need a full-service agency with expertise in various areas of social media marketing.

  • Require scalability to handle campaigns of varying sizes and complexities.

  • Value a data-driven approach to social media strategy and execution.

  • Seek a partner who can offer innovative ideas and stay ahead of industry trends.

Ultimately, the best choice depends on your specific needs and priorities. Consider factors such as budget, goals, desired level of control, and the complexity of your social media strategy before making a decision. If you're unsure, reach out to agencies like Buter Up social media to discuss your needs and see if their services align with your goals.



Read more from our in house

ai, social media, and marketing experts

March 08, 2024 I 5 min read

April 20th, 2024 I 6 min read

December 18, 2024 I 7 min read